When planning the installation of a new fireplace, you will have complete control over the type, size, appearance, and brand of the fireplace you choose. However, certain features of your home may limit your choices as to the fuel source of your fireplace and where the fireplace is installed. The location of gas lines in your home, the cost of gas vs electric utilities, and your personal preferences will all factor into your decision. Here is your ultimate comparison guide to choosing between a gas vs electric fireplace
Key Differences Between Gas & Electric Fireplaces
Exploring the key differences between gas and electric fireplaces will make it easier for you to choose between the two. The most important factors to consider are:
- Ease of Installation – Electric fireplaces are typically faster and easier to install. Installing a gas fireplace requires collaboration from professionals, as well as installing venting and exhaust and connecting gas lines.
- Performance and Energy Efficiency – Electric fireplaces are considered more energy-efficient than gas. They convert nearly all of their energy to heat, which allows them to heat small areas very effectively. Gas fireplaces only convert about 70-90% of their energy to heat, as more heat is lost through venting. However, a gas fireplace’s heat output (BTU) is higher and the fireplace can heat a larger room faster. An electric fireplace’s heat output is lower and isn’t ideal for larger spaces or as a supplemental heat source.
- Cost – A gas fireplace may be more expensive to install, but it is less expensive to operate. Electric fireplaces are less expensive to install but may cost more to operate depending on electricity rates in your area.
- Safety – Most experts consider electric fireplaces to be safer because they don’t produce real flames. This means there is no risk of carbon monoxide poisoning or harmful emissions. There are also no open flames, which reduces the risk of a house fire or harm or injury to children and pets. Electric fireplaces can be installed closer to walls without requiring extra clearance for venting or exhaust, so they are safe for smaller spaces.
- Maintenance and Upkeep – Electric fireplaces require much less care, cleaning, and maintenance compared to gas fireplaces. They do not need annual inspections, flue cleaning, or gas line servicing. You may need to clean the surface of the glass and surrounding areas to remove dust, replace light bulbs or LED lights, and check electrical cords and power sources for damage. Gas fireplaces must have an annual inspection to ensure safe, efficient operation and proper venting. You must regularly clean the glass door, burner, and flue and check and adjust the pilot light. They must also undergo regular checks to make sure there are no gas leaks and that all gas lines and connections are secure.
- Aesthetics – A gas fireplace mimics the appearance of a wood-burning fireplace as it uses real flames. Electric fireplaces use LED technology to imitate the appearance of flames.
What to Consider Before Gas Fireplace Installation
The gas fireplace installation process can be lengthy and requires permits and inspections as well as collaboration with a team of professionals. Other factors to consider are that gas fireplaces:
- Can heat a larger space more efficiently
- Create a more authentic flame appearance and flame sounds
- Require access to natural gas lines and gas service
- Increase the risk of harmful emissions like carbon monoxide
What to Consider Before Electric Fireplace Installation
Before installing an electric fireplace, you should consider your room size and layout, access to electrical outlets and wiring, and any modifications an electrician may need to make to your home’s electrical system or electrical panel to account for a heavier load. Other factors to consider are that electric fireplaces:
- Are faster, easier, and more affordable to install
- May cost more to operate depending on electric costs in your area
- Can be used to supplement heat sources in larger rooms or make small rooms more comfortable
- Require less care and maintenance
- They are safer as they don’t produce harmful emissions
How Long Do Gas Fireplaces Last vs. Electric Fireplaces?
If a gas fireplace is properly operated, maintained, cleaned, and regularly inspected, it can last 20-25 years. Electric fireplaces can last between 10-20 years, depending on usage frequency, quality of the unit, whether it was properly installed, and how often it is inspected and maintained.
Does an Electric Fireplace Need a Chimney?
No, an electric fireplace doesn’t need a chimney because it doesn’t use real flames or produce smoke or harmful emissions. It can be plugged into an outlet without the need for installing a ventilation or exhaust system.
At EmberWest, We Can Help You Choose the Right Fireplace
At EmberWest, we specialize in high-quality, beautiful, and efficient fireplace systems. We are a fireplace and patio service provider for the San Jose area. When you visit our showroom, we can demonstrate the operation of gas and electric fireplaces, go over their features and benefits, and help you compare the pros and cons of each. We will answer any questions and explain what to expect from the installation process, depending on the type of fireplace you choose. Contact us now to learn more about our selection, or visit our showroom and speak with one of our experienced salespeople.